←back to Blog

Is Social Security Running Dry or Staying Afloat?

When it comes to the future of Social Security, you’ve likely seen headlines like this: “Social Security faces earlier depletion date” or “Washington ignores America’s fiscal cliff.” 

Perhaps you’ve come away with a sense that Social Security in the U.S. is headed toward insolvency. If so, you’re not alone.  

“There’s a really common misperception where a lot of people think that Social Security isn’t going to exist in the future,” says Megan Weber, an assistant professor of marketing at the Kellogg School who researches how people understand public policy.  

The truth is that absent any Congressional action, Social Security payments won’t vanish anytime soon for the millions of Americans who rely on them. If the program stays on its current trajectory, those payments will get smaller—likely reduced to about 80 percent of what they are today—but they won’t run dry. 

Weber—along with her colleagues Stephen Spiller and Hal Hershfield of the University of California, Los Angeles, and Suzanne Shu of Cornell University—investigated why this misperception is so prevalent. They suspected that it had something to do with people’s understanding of the way money enters and exits Social Security trust funds.  

The researchers conducted a series of experiments to test how people’s perception of Social Security’s future changed when prompted to think about its “flows” (the money entering Social Security funds through payroll taxes and coming out as payments) versus its “stock” (the amount of money currently held in the funds). They found that people were more likely to understand that the safety-net program would continue, albeit with reduced payouts, if they were prompted to think about flows rather than stocks.  

Even small tweaks to the way information about Social Security was presented made a big difference in how people processed their existing knowledge.  

“We find that [these small tweaks] can be quite effective in decreasing the percentage of people who have these zero-benefits beliefs,” Weber says. “We’re kind of leading them along the garden path, encouraging them to have this ‘aha moment,’ without necessarily telling them anything extra.” 

Flows and stock 

Media reports often depict Social Security as a pool of money slowly draining. But the more-accurate metaphor for the flows of the system might be a bathtub.   


Insight in your inbox

Receive our newsletters to keep up with the latest research and ideas from faculty at the Kellogg School of Management.

https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/newsletter/insightful-leader


In a bathtub, the water that pours from the faucet into the tub is the inflow, the water leaving the tub through the drain is the outflow, and any water in the tub is the stock. 

If the inflow is greater than the outflow, then the stock in the tub will increase. If the opposite is true, and the water drains faster than it’s replaced, then the stock will decrease. But in either scenario, there is water both going into and out of the tub; even if the tub itself is empty, there’s inflow going straight into the outflow. 

In the context of Social Security, payroll taxes provide the inflow; payments to retirees and disabled Americans provide the outflow. And the balance left in the Social Security trust funds is the stock. Because outflows are currently happening faster than inflows—meaning that benefits payments are being made at a higher rate than taxes are putting money in—models project the trust funds’ stock could deplete in the next decade. But just as water continues to flow into the bathtub, payroll taxes will still be adding money. And future payments will carry on, though they will likely end up being smaller because taxes aren’t keeping up with benefits obligations. 

Still, many Americans worry that the bathtub will run dry and benefits will end, despite the fact that water/funds will continue to enter and exit the tub. The researchers suspected that people are overly focused on the Social Security trust funds’ stock and not paying enough attention to the money flowing through them, perhaps spurred on by alarmist headlines about the system’s looming demise.  

Moving away from zero-benefits beliefs 

To test their hypothesis, the researchers asked 1,000 online participants to read a brief description of Social Security that explained where the trust funds’ income comes from, where the payments go, and when the funds are likely to reach a $0 balance. Then they showed each of the participants either a graph depicting the trust funds’ balance (the stock) or a graph depicting income and expenditures (the flows). 

They found that which graph a participant saw made a difference: 64 percent of participants who saw the stock graph said that Social Security benefits were going to go away completely when the trust funds depleted, compared with 56 percent of those who saw the flows graph.

When asked how much money retirees who currently expect $1,000 a month would get after the trust funds’ depletion, those who saw the flow graph entered a higher amount on average ($314) than those who saw the stock graph did ($239). (For these averages, people who said the benefits would go away completely were counted as entering $0.) But because of the prevalence of zero-benefits beliefs, both groups were more pessimistic than they needed to be; projections indicate that retirees who currently get $1,000 a month would get $750 to $800 when the trust funds run out. 

Similar results emerged in several follow-up experiments that varied the way the inflow and outflow charts were displayed. 

“When we show people flows graphs that focus on the amount of money coming in and the amount of money going out, we find that they are less likely to have the zero-benefits beliefs,” Weber says, “suggesting that getting people thinking about the fact that there will still be taxes coming in and still payments going out helps them reason through this system a little better.” 

Invoking Benjamin Franklin 

While the flows graphs helped steer people away from a zero-benefits belief, more than half of participants in both groups still thought that the benefits were going to disappear. “So there’s a lot of room to improve,” Weber says. 

The researchers decided to explore this further in another experiment inspired by Benjamin Franklin’s famous saying that nothing in life is certain except death and taxes.  

This experiment was similar in design except for one key difference: participants answered two self-reflection questions, either before or after reporting what they thought would happen to benefits. The first question asked if participants thought Social Security would continue to collect payroll taxes after the trust funds were depleted. The second asked what participants thought Social Security would do with the money if payroll taxes continued to be collected. These two questions prompted people to think through what would happen with the payroll taxes Social Security collected (that is, the inflow).  

Weber and her colleagues found that these questions about future taxes, when asked before the questions about future benefits, proved very effective in moving people away from a zero-benefits belief. Only 39 percent of participants who answered the self-reflection questions before the benefits question said they thought benefits would go away—significantly lower than the percentages in the prior experiments (about 56-to-64 percent).  

What’s more, participants who saw the flows graphs and also answered the self-reflection questions before the benefits questions estimated that retirees would receive $404 a month—the most-accurate estimate across all groups. 

“I was pleasantly surprised at how big this effect was,” Weber says, especially since they didn’t give participants any new information about Social Security. They just prompted them to think a little differently about what they already knew.  

“These are things that people probably do know,” she says. “It just might be that they’re not connecting the dots when they’re thinking about Social Security and seeing all these scary headlines about how it’s headed towards insolvency.” 

Beyond Social Security 

The challenge of accurately predicting inflows, outflows, and stocks extends far beyond Social Security. From inventory at a coffee company to subscriptions for a streaming service to the accumulation of greenhouse gases, all sorts of operations rely on the same basic principles.  

“There are a lot of accumulation-related questions that are about resources and how the government and people and organizations have to manage them as inflows and outflows and stocks change over time,” Weber says. 

With this idea in mind, the researchers explored whether they might be able to generalize their findings in a slightly different experimental scenario. This time, the team presented 1,002 participants with the description of a fictional battery manufacturer that was shipping out batteries faster than it could produce them. Overall, those who saw flows graphs and who answered the self-reflection questions before predicting outflows were the most likely to correctly estimate the amount of batteries the company would continue to ship out once its stock was depleted. 

Collectively, the experiments underscore the effectiveness of subtly shifting people’s focus when they are thinking through complex systems.  

“Whether it’s Social Security or water in a reservoir or inventory at a company, if we emphasize the depleting stock, people might get stuck on the thing that’s running out, versus if we talk about flows,” Weber says.