Gillian Blease/Ikon Images
When fast-casual restaurant chain Sweetgreen had its 2021 initial public offering, it highlighted its customizable salads (like the Super Green Goddess) and bowls (like the Chicken Pesto Parm). “Our single most popular item is the ‘custom’ salad or bowl, which can include millions of combinations from 40-plus ingredients,” the 140-location company stated on its Securities and Exchange Commission registration form. Those orders translated into a significant portion of its business: The company reported that “custom orders represented approximately 25% of our revenue for our fiscal year to date through September 26, 2021.”
Sweetgreen touted how easy specially made orders could be for return customers. Regulars could save their favorite custom-made items in the Sweetgreen app and reorder them in seconds. (“I get a custom salad but the same one every single time,” noted one fan on Reddit.) Making customization easy also had positive effects for Sweetgreen: By demonstrating that custom meals didn’t have to be just for special occasions or for customers with tricky food restrictions — and that they didn’t require much work for the shopper — the company was able to build loyalty across transactions and across its customer base.
Many companies struggle to launch successful customization journeys. We’ve found that, in part, this occurs because customers are reluctant to give it a try. Our research, forthcoming in the Journal of Marketing, revealed that it’s often not enough for retailers to offer customers a choice between ready-made products and the option to customize with add-on options for base products. Customers need to be persuaded. If retailers can convince customers to try customization even once, this initial experience transforms their relationship with the retailer. In this article, we explain why the customization journey is dynamic rather than static and provide guidance for breaking through customers’ initial hesitancy.
Customers Love Customization — Don’t They?
Abundant research shows that people who customize products like them better and are more satisfied with them than those who choose among ready-made products. Customization gives buyers the power to create products that are more closely aligned with their preferences. Further, involvement in product creation can increase buyers’ satisfaction by making them feel more accomplished — sometimes called the “I designed it myself” effect.
Advances in technology have made it possible for companies selling products as varied as cars (Volkswagen’s Vehicle Builder, Configure Your Rolls-Royce), insurance (GEICO), sneakers (Nike By You, Vans), and fast casual food (Chipotle, Cava, Sweetgreen) to offer mass customization via online platforms. Customization requires customers to engage in the process; it’s different from personalization (such as Amazon’s personalized recommendation system), which incorporates customer input but does not allow the customer to make choices among features or cocreate the output.
However, despite advances on the operational side, buyers tend to be reluctant to opt into customization when it is offered. This has been a perennial problem: A 2015 study from Deloitte found that although the majority of those surveyed (1,560 adults in Great Britain) were aware of product customization, only 16% had actually purchased a customized product. More recently, a fashion retailer we worked with offered customization in most of its clothing categories, but only 8% of its buyers ever customized over a nine-year period.
What’s behind the hesitancy? Our work builds on previous findings that customers tend to worry that choosing from an array of options will take more effort than choosing among ready-made products, and they are not sure that the combination of options they choose will be better than a standard product. For customers, opting into customization requires the belief that the time and effort spent on the process — as well as the money, if customization ends up costing more — will generate value and lead to better outcomes.
Once Customers Try It, They Like It
Our research found that trying customization even once can change buyers’ perceptions about the costs and benefits of customization and increase the likelihood that they will customize again.
We started by analyzing nine years of transaction data from a men’s and women’s clothing retailer that offered customization in most of its product categories (shirts, pants, jackets, suits, and dresses). Buyers who customized at least once returned to stores more often, bought more items, and spent more for 24 months after their initial customization experience than buyers who never customized, making them significantly more valuable customers.
Is this because buyers who opt into customization are somehow different from those who don’t? It’s possible that customizers were more loyal to the retailer even before their customization experience, which could explain why they tended to buy and spend more. To test whether it was process engagement rather than differences between customizers and noncustomizers that boosted sales, we conducted three longitudinal experiments with hundreds of participants (429 completed both sessions in Experiment 1, as did 440 participants in Experiment 2 and 378 in Experiment 3). People made real design decisions via online configurators for two different products (e-postcards sent to a friend or family member, and vinyl stickers for their laptop, phone, or water bottle) and used the customized products before coming back three weeks later. Randomly assigning participants to either customize their products or choose among ready-made products allowed us to address the concern that those who opt into customization might be different from those who don’t.
We found that buyers randomly assigned to customize products evaluated their purchases and the retailer more favorably. They also were more than twice as likely to opt into customization again three weeks later, repeating the cycle. Clearly, it was a win-win.
These studies show that happy customizers don’t need to be “born” — they can be created. If retailers can get their customers to engage in early customization, they can build more valuable customer relationships.
How to Launch the Customization Journey
So how can companies encourage people to opt into customization? We’re not suggesting that managers randomly assign people to customize. Instead, to start this virtuous cycle, managers can take several steps that encourage buyers to give it a try. Here are five ways to design a process that breaks through customer reluctance.
1. Let customers know that customization is an option — and that other customers like it.
Without encouragement, customers who have not previously opted into customization are unlikely to try it on their own. Our research found that by sharing positive feedback about the process from other clients, retailers can overcome buyer inertia and get customers to change their pattern of choosing a ready-made option.
In one of our studies, we told some participants (truthfully) that customization had generated higher satisfaction among previous research participants. Fifty-two percent of those who were told that customizers had been more satisfied opted into customization — nearly twice as many as those who did not receive that message (28%). This initial experience increased their subsequent willingness to customize, leading to more positive evaluations of both the product and retailer three weeks later.
2. Provide financial incentives to try out customization.
One common reason buyers give for not opting into customization is that it is more expensive. An easy way to address this issue is to offer a promotion for first-time customizers. Eliminating the price differential and reducing the financial barrier for the first customization experience has the potential to more than make up for the discount, given that customizers tend to spend more, buy more items, and visit more frequently than noncustomizers, as our research found.
3. Reduce customization effort by offering starting points and being selective about options.
Customization via starting solutions — where customers begin by selecting a predesigned product and then refine its attributes to customize it further rather than building it attribute-by-attribute from the beginning — can reduce the perceived effort required and improve performance. Sweetgreen has a base of curated, signature, and seasonal items that customers can start from. Returning customers using the company’s app can make modifications to previously ordered items or start from scratch. Nike By You offers six to eight designs of each style of shoe as inspiration, allowing customers to see a range of finished products before beginning their own customization process.
It’s also important to reduce choice overload. Having more options is attractive to customers, but too many options can be overwhelming and cause customers to discontinue the customization process. The MTailor app has navigated this well: It offers a limited, curated set of customization options (such as buttons, collars, and pockets) as its default, to facilitate decision-making for those who are new to bespoke clothing. For experts or experienced customers who are able to handle a wider range of features, MTailor allows users to click “more options” to expand the number of choices available.
Luxury brands in particular should be selective about the options they offer, in the interest of preserving the luxury image of the final product. Allowing consumers to make too many design decisions can erode the value of the brand. LVMH’s TAG Heuer limits customers to selecting their watch’s face color and strap from very limited options. Hermès allows buyers to select the exterior color, interior color, marking, and typography for its Calvi card Holder, but buyers are given a modest palette of options consistent with the brand’s opulent image.
4. Help customers visualize the customization outcome.
Our research found that providing strong visualization and immediate feedback can help buyers avoid poor combinations of features and result in a more positive evaluation of the finished product. Specifically, an online configurator that allows buyers to preview the combination of features they have selected before they finalize the design can reduce the frequency of customer regret. Just as importantly, having the ability to preview the combination they selected reduces the customer’s fear of a poor outcome.
Another way to reduce fears about poor outcomes is to offer online or in-person help. Sometimes customers have a lot of experience expressing their preferences (such as when they’re ordering a pizza using the Domino’s build-your-own platform), but customization can feel difficult when they have less understanding of their preferences. In such cases, salespeople can provide valuable assistance. Ann Mashburn’s Made to Order option, which allows buyers to select a fabric and style and have a customized shirt, dress, or skirt made in a standard size, walks buyers through the customization process, both online and in its retail stores.
5. Provide a remedy for customers who don’t like their final product.
Another fear customers have expressed is that after they invest time and money in customizing a product, it can be difficult to return it if they don’t like it. Although companies cannot put customized products back on the shelf, it may be good business to support unhappy customizers when the products they create don’t meet their expectations. Offering “remakes” rather than refunds is one strategy. It also makes it less likely that buyers will order multiple items with the intent of returning all but one. MTailor customers attribute their loyalty to the company in part to supportive customer service that provides free remakes to get the features and fit right.
The Business Upside
Customization can be especially profitable when demand is unpredictable or inventory holding costs are high, such as in the automotive industry, but making products to order offers advantages in many common categories where trends change (such as fashion) or products become less fresh over time (such as salads or bowls). Sweetgreen touts its Infinite Kitchen technology, which allows employees to quickly assemble bowls and plates to customers’ specifications. The parent company of MTailor, Bit Body, developed an app to translate each customer’s order into a cut-ready apparel pattern, allowing the business to scale production. Because customized products generate higher purchase intentions and willingness to pay, companies that successfully work through the operational challenges can generate higher returns.
Beyond the advantages for every sale of a customized product, our research illustrates the longer-term advantages of introducing buyers to customization. For the fashion retailer we worked with, buyers who customized were systematically more profitable, returned to stores more often, bought more items, and spent more over the next 24 months than buyers who never customized. Our follow-up experiments with hundreds of participants who customized and used products show that retailers can generate more favorable evaluations of both the product and their brand over time by encouraging buyers to opt into customization.
The sooner retailers encourage buyers to do so, the more time both they and their buyers have to benefit from a mutually beneficial relationship.